Artist: I.N.J Culbard
A Page 45 Comic Book of the Month
“Chief Superintendent Carstairs: What the did, they did with the most principled intentions.
Chief Inspector George Suttle: They
ruined the world, Carstairs.”
In the week that Margaret Thatcher
died, it is hard to think about Dan Abnett and I.N.J Culbard's “The
New Deadwardians” without reading a condemnation of the former
Prime Minister's policies into the narrative. For some she was a
figure to be admired, somebody who got Britain respected in the world
community again. The Daily Mail newspaper had the headline, “The
Woman Who Saved Britain” on the morning following her death. For
others it was a cause for unprecedented celebration. Whatever one's
political stance, the one thing that can be said for certain is that,
in light of the diametrically opposed reactions to her passing, she
was a divisive figure who left a divided country.
The theme of a divided Britain, along
lines of class and class privilege, runs right through this book. Some
sort of disease has run through the working class, turning them into
mindless zombies, greedy for human flesh. To combat this the ruling
classes took what they called the “Cure” which turned them into
vampires. The poor were kept in zones away from the ruling classes
who were now immortal, or at least unable to die as they were already
dead. There are demonstrations and riots by the common folk who have
not succumbed to the curse. This all seems very symbolic of Britain in the Eighties.
Chief Inspector George Suttle is the
last homicide detective left in the Metropolitan Police. His
department has all but been dissolved as there are no murders, at
least among the vampiric ruling classes; until one of them turns up
dead with none of the three known ways they can die (impalement of
the heart, decapitation and incineration). The subsequent
investigation leads him right up to the very highest power in the
land.
Our protagonist comes across as a
decent sort of man. He looks after his elderly and infirm mother, he
dislikes the derogatory term “brights”, which is used to refer to
the common folk who are not zombies, He takes his maid for the cure
after she is bitten by a zombie, and speaks respectfully to all he
comes across. He is haunted by memories of the war fought against the
zombies in 1861, and the acts he had to commit for Queen and Country.
It is through Suttle's musings that we come to the second main theme
of the book, that of the nature of life. In giving up their lives to
become undead, they lose all their old desires, dreams and
motivations. They lose all that made life worth living and so for
them they are merely existing. Some are able to fool themselves, but
like Antoine Roquentin in Satre's Nausea, Suttle is tormented by the
existentialist dilemma. In living forever they have lost their life. They are no longer living, merely existing.
There is much to like about this book. I.N.J. Culbard produces some attractive art. Detailed backgrounds are used where they are required to communicate some crucial part of the story (e.g. the Houses of Parliament where the murder victim is found, and for all establishing shots). However for large parts of the book the backgrounds are blank. This helps focus the eye on the characters, emphasising where the importance lies – this is a book about people and how they are treated. There is also a symbolic element to this, as the walls remain empty of décor and detail in the same way that the lives of the vampires are empty.
Dan Abnett's script is tight. He
manages to tie everything up in eight issues where some would have
tried to string it out as long as possible. His dialogue is realistic
and there are some nice, humorous touches, as in the following
exchange between Suttle and his driver Bowes:
“George Suttle: I'm not familiar with
the area myself. I live in Zone-A, Marylebone.
Bowes (muttering): You don't live
nowhere at all, mate.”
Unfortunately
there are some areas where this strip lets itself down, not least in
it's treatment of women. There are only really four women characters
in it. Suttle's mother serves to comment on George himself. George's
maid is there to be a victim of a zombie attack so we can see how
wonderful Suttle is. Sapphire, the whore who falls for George
incredibly quickly and for no discernible reason other than it served
the plot as she later becomes a kidnap victim. The murder victim's
mother is there to mourn her husband, and her daughter is a
stereotypical firebrand feminist who is defined by her stance
against men. It is perhaps a little unfair to pick up on this here as
The New Deadwardians is far from alone in this depiction of women,
and I don't think it was a deliberate decision to have all the
females defined by the relationship to men, but it stands out in a
book which appears to want to point out the problems with social
inequality due to class.
These
gender issues are a shame as this is otherwise a wonderful book, with
memorable scenes and with a desire to say something, to reflect
something about our society. I'd still recommend purchasing this as
it is well written, but the problems with gender are to the detriment
of the work as a whole.
I've yet to read this, so forgive me if the following thought seems trite. I wonder if the treatment of female characters in this story is a result of an, admittedly heavy-handed, attempt to reflect general attitudes towards women in the historical setting that the story is paralleling? Perhaps this is too kind and the story is simply another example of how male comics creators often slip up where female characters are concerned.
ReplyDeletePossibly I'm being a little unfair on the book. It's not the attitudes the characters show towards women, but more the way the women are actually depicted as being either thinking about the men or victims in need of rescuing. Although these may have been the attitudes of the time, the creators can still depict the women as three diemensional characters who suffer under these attitudes. It did cross my mind that I may just be criticising genre tropes, but these are tropes that really should not have a place in the modern day, and sometimes it is not until readers and creators start being conciously aware, and conciously questioning of the perceptions they are perpetuating, that change comes about.
ReplyDeleteI suppose it's a little like the depiction of black people in the forties and fifties, with Eisner's Ebony a prime example. To modern eyes, Ebony is a vile stereotype. Yet there is no doubt that Eisner was no racist and was totally unaware of just how offensive a character he was. I don't think, based on his work, that Dan Abnett is particularly sexist, but there seem to be sexist elements to this book of which he may no doubt be totally unaware.
Gender in comics is something I've been reading about recently so it may just be that it's stuck on my brain and I'm totally misreading it.
Oh, forgot to say, thanks for the comment. It certainly made me go back and rethink my stance.
ReplyDeleteI don't think you're misreading anything. There's no right and wrong here, I just wanted to start a discussion. I think a look over Abnett's other work would provide an insight as to whether he has sexist tendencies, or if, as you say, he is simply unaware that his treatment of female characters could be read in this way. Equally, I do wonder if, in this case, the perceived sexism is intentional. I need to get my copy back so I can read it.
ReplyDeleteIt's a good read. He's never struck me as particularly sexist, but he writes almost exclusively in the adventure genre aimed mainly at men/boys so it's easy, as a male to overlook it, especially when you've grown up reading the stuff.
ReplyDeleteI think the genre itself tends towards male characters, with the females being mainly victims or objects of sexual desire, dressed up sexually alluring clothes or, more usually, partially clothed. Alan Moore was tried to combat with Halo Jones, with gender roles reversed from the traditional adventure tale. Terry Moore also makes a valiant effort with Strangers in Paradise, and Gail Simone does a grand job of showing how it should be done in almost all her work.